Бхагавадгита 18.12 Bhagavadgītā 18.12 — 11 переводов, 2 комментария

Сравнение русских переводов и санскритских комментариев «Бхагавадгиты» — стих за стихом.

Переводы

Петров 1788

bhagavadgita-1788
aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam ।
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit ॥

Казначеева 1909

bhagavadgita-1909
aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam ।
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit ॥

Каменская и де Манциарли 1914

bhagavadgita-1914
aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam ।
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit ॥

Смирнов 1977

bhagavadgita-smirnov
aniṣṭamiṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam । БхГ 18.12
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu sannyāsināṃ kvacit ॥12 БхГ 18.12॥

Прабхупада 1984

bhagavadgita-prabhupada
aniṣṭamiṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam |
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu sannyāsināṃ kvacit || 12 ||

Семенцов 1999

bhagavadgita-sementsov
aniṣṭamiṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam । БхГ 18.12
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu sannyāsināṃ kvacit ॥12 БхГ 18.12॥

Эрман 2009

bhagavadgita-erman
aniṣṭamiṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam । БхГ 18.12
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu sannyāsināṃ kvacit ॥12 БхГ 18.12॥

Бурба 2009

bhagavadgita-burba
18.12 aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam |
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit ||

Шри Шарма 2015

bhagavadgita-sharma
aniṣṭamiṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam ।
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu sannyāsināṃ kvacit ॥ BhG 18.12॥

Блиндерман 2016

bhagavadgita-radha
aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca, tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam
bhavaty atyāgināṃ pretya, na tu sannyāsināṃ kvacit|| BhG 18.12
Сборники

Сборник переводов 1788–2016

bhagavadgity
अनिष्टमिष्टं मिश्रं च त्रिविधं कर्मणः फलम् ।
भवत्यत्यागिनां प्रेत्य न तु सन्न्यासिनां क्वचित् ॥ १२ ॥

aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam ।
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit ॥

Комментарии

Рамануджа. Гитабхашья

ramanuja_gitabhashya
aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam |
bhavaty atyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit || BhG_18.12
aniṣṭam iṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam | bhavaty atyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit ||
aniṣṭam narakādiphalam, iṣṭam svargādi, miśram aniṣṭasaṃbhinnaṃ putrapaśvannādyādi; etat trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam, atyāginām kartṛtvamamatāphalatyāgarahitānāṃ pretya bhavati / pretya karmānuṣṭhānottarakālam ityarthaḥ / na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit -- na tu kartṛtvādiparityāgināṃ kvacid api mokṣavirodhi phalaṃ bhavati / etad uktaṃ bhavati -- yady apy agnihotramahāyajñādīni tāny eva, tathāpi jīvanādhikārakāmādhikārayor iva mokṣādhikāre ca viniyogapṛthaktvena parihriyate / mokṣaviniyogaś ca, "tam etaṃ vedānuvacanena brāhmaṇā vividiṣanti yajñena dānena tapasānāśakena" ityādibhir iti / tad evaṃ kriyamāṇeṣv eva karmasu kartṛtvādiparityāgaḥ śāstrasiddhiḥ saṃnyāsaḥ; sa eva ca tyāga ity uktaḥ // (BhGR_18.12)
aniṣṭam naraka-ādi-phalam, iṣṭam svarga-ādi, miśram aniṣṭa-saṃbhinnaṃ putra-paśv-anna-adya-ādi; etat tri-vidhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam, atyāginām kartṛtva-mamatā-phala-tyāga-rahitānāṃ pretya bhavati / pretya karma-anuṣṭhāna-uttara-kālam ity-arthaḥ / na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit --- na tu kartṛtva-ādi-parityāgināṃ kvacid api mokṣa-virodhi phalaṃ bhavati / etad uktaṃ bhavati --- yady apy agni-hotra-mahā-yajña-ādīni tāny eva, tatha āpi jīvana-adhikāra-kāma-adhikārayor iva mokṣa-adhikāre ca viniyoga-pṛthaktvena parihriyate / mokṣa-viniyogaś ca, "tam etaṃ veda-anuvacanena brāhmaṇā vividiṣanti yajñena dānena tapasa ānāśakena" ity-ādibhir iti / tad evaṃ kriyamāṇeṣv eva karmasu kartṛtva-ādi-parityāgaḥ śāstra-siddhiḥ saṃnyāsaḥ; sa eva ca tyāga ity uktaḥ //
idānīṃ bhagavati puruṣottame antaryāmiṇi kartṛtvānusaṃdhānena ātmani akartṛtvānusaṃdhānaprakāram āha, tata eva phalakarmaṇor api mamatāparityāgo bhavatīti / paramapuruṣo hi svakīyena jīvātmanā svakīyaiś ca karaṇakalevaraprāṇaiḥ svalīlāprayojanāya karmāṇy ārabhate / ato jīvātmagataṃ kṣunnivṛttyādikam api phalam, tatsādhanabhūtaṃ ca karma paramapuruṣasyaiva / (BhGR_p417695)
idānīṃ bhagavati puruṣa-uttame antaryāmiṇi kartṛtva-anusaṃdhānena ātmani akartṛtva-anusaṃdhāna-prakāram āha, tata eva phala-karmaṇor api mamatā-parityāgo bhavati iti / parama-puruṣo hi svakīyena jīva-ātmanā svakīyaiś ca karaṇa-kalevara-prāṇaiḥ sva-līlā-prayojanāya karmāṇy ārabhate / ato jīva-ātma-gataṃ kṣun-nivṛtty-ādikam api phalam, tat-sādhana-bhūtaṃ ca karma parama-puruṣasya eva /

Абхинавагупта. Гитартхасанграха

gitarthasamgraha-abhinavagupta
aniṣṭamiṣṭaṃ miśraṃ ca trividhaṃ karmaṇaḥ phalam |
bhavatyatyāgināṃ pretya na tu saṃnyāsināṃ kvacit ||12||

atyāginām — phalamayānām ||12||
adhunā vyavahāradaśāyāmapi pañcasvapi karmahetuṣu sthiteṣu balādevāmī avidyāndhāḥ pumāṃsaḥ svātmanyeva sakalakartṛbhāvabhāramāropayanti | ato nijayaiva dhiyātmānaṃ badhnanti, natu vastusthityā asya bandhaḥ - ityupadiśyate-