Бхагавадгита 18.19 Bhagavadgītā 18.19 — 11 переводов, 2 комментария

Сравнение русских переводов и санскритских комментариев «Бхагавадгиты» — стих за стихом.

Переводы

Петров 1788

bhagavadgita-1788
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇa-bhedataḥ ।
procyate guṇa-saṃkhyāne yathāvac chṛṇu tānyapi ॥

Казначеева 1909

bhagavadgita-1909
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇa-bhedataḥ ।
procyate guṇa-saṃkhyāne yathāvac chṛṇu tānyapi ॥

Каменская и де Манциарли 1914

bhagavadgita-1914
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇa-bhedataḥ ।
procyate guṇa-saṃkhyāne yathāvac chṛṇu tānyapi ॥

Смирнов 1977

bhagavadgita-smirnov
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇabhedataḥ । БхГ 18.19
procyate guṇasaṅkhyāne yathāvacchṛṇu tānyapi ॥19 БхГ 18.19॥

Прабхупада 1984

bhagavadgita-prabhupada
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇabhedataḥ |
procyate guṇasaṅkhyāne yathāvacchṛṇu tānyapi || 19 ||

Семенцов 1999

bhagavadgita-sementsov
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇabhedataḥ । БхГ 18.19
procyate guṇasaṅkhyāne yathāvacchṛṇu tānyapi ॥19 БхГ 18.19॥

Эрман 2009

bhagavadgita-erman
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇabhedataḥ । БхГ 18.19
procyate guṇasaṅkhyāne yathāvacchṛṇu tānyapi ॥19 БхГ 18.19॥

Бурба 2009

bhagavadgita-burba
18.19 jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇa-bhedataḥ |
procyate guṇa-saṃkhyāne yathāvac chṛṇu tānyapi ||

Шри Шарма 2015

bhagavadgita-sharma
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇabhedataḥ ।
procyate guṇasaṅkhyāne yathāvacchṛṇu tānyapi ॥ BhG 18.19॥

Блиндерман 2016

bhagavadgita-radha
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca, tridhaiva guṇa-bhedataḥ
procyate guṇa-saṅkhyāne, yathāvac chṛṇu tāny api|| BhG 18.19
Сборники

Сборник переводов 1788–2016

bhagavadgity
ज्ञानं कर्म च कर्ता च त्रिधैव गुणभेदतः ।
प्रोच्यते गुणसङ्ख्याने यथावच्छृणु तान्यपि ॥ १९ ॥

jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇa-bhedataḥ ।
procyate guṇa-saṃkhyāne yathāvac chṛṇu tānyapi ॥

Комментарии

Рамануджа. Гитабхашья

ramanuja_gitabhashya
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇabhedataḥ /
procyate guṇasaṃkhyāne yathāvac chṛṇu tāny api // BhG_18.19
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridha aiva guṇa-bhedataḥ / procyate guṇa-saṃkhyāne yathāvac chṛṇu tāny api //
kartavyakarmaviṣayaṃ jñānam, anuṣṭhīyamānaṃ ca karma, tasyānuṣṭhātā ca sattvādiguṇabhedatas trividhaiva procyate guṇasaṃkhyāne guṇakāryagaṇane / yathāvac chṛṇu tāny api tāni guṇato bhinnāni jñānādīni yathāvac chṛṇu // (BhGR_18.19)
kartavya-karma-viṣayaṃ jñānam, anuṣṭhīyamānaṃ ca karma, tasya anuṣṭhātā ca sattva-ādi-guṇa-bhedatas tri-vidha aiva procyate guṇa-saṃkhyāne guṇa-kārya-gaṇane / yathāvac chṛṇu tāny api tāni guṇato bhinnāni jñāna-ādīni yathāvac chṛṇu //

Абхинавагупта. Гитартхасанграха

gitarthasamgraha-abhinavagupta
jñānaṃ karma ca kartā ca tridhaiva guṇabhedataḥ |
procyate guṇasaṅkhyāne yathāvacchṛṇu tānyapi ||19||

guṇānāṃ saṅkhyānaṃ - niścayo yatra tatra sāṅkhyīyakṛtānte jñānādi trividhamucyate yattacchṛṇviti saṅgatiḥ | jñānam - ityanena jñāne kriyāyāṃ ca yatkaraṇaṃ tadvividha- muktam| evaṃ karmeti jñeyaṃ kāryaṃ ca | jñātā kartā ceti ||19||
tatra 'sarvabhūteṣu' ityādinā ślokatrayeṇa jñānakaraṇasya trairūpyamuktam| ata eva 'yena' - iti tṛtīyā | iyatā ca jñānakaraṇasāmānyasya svarūpamuktam | 'niyatam' ityādinā ślokatrayeṇa karmaṇo jñeyakāryarūpasya dvaividhyam| 'muktasaṅgaḥ' ityādinā ślokatrayeṇa tu karturdvirūpasya saṅkṣepeṇa svarūpam | karaṇaviśeṣasya svarūpabheda- pratipādanārthaṃ buddhestraividhyaṃ nirūpitam, tadvāreṇa karaṇāntarāṇāmapi traividhya- mupalakṣitam| karaṇasya tvitikartavyatāpekṣitvāditikartavyatāyāśca dhṛtyādipañcaka- rūpatve'pi śraddhāyāḥ pūrvamuktatvādvividiṣāvividiṣayośca dhṛtisukhābhyāmākṣepāttayo- straividhyaṃ ‘dhṛtyā yayā' ityanena, 'sukhaṃ tvidānīm ' - ityanena coktam | tadāha